Most overrated PC game? You tell me.
February 29th, 2012
I've been thinking this week about the most overrated PC game. And by overrated I mean overhyped, overstated, whatever. Basically, any game that's the recipient of undue praise or attention.
Most people would argue the top nominations are often good to very good games. They're just not as great, revolutionary, or masterpiece-worthy as fans and critics often say they are.
After thinking about the issue for — oh, maybe 15 minutes — here are two games that come to my mind.
- Bioshock — Before you ready the tar and feathers, hear me out. Bioshock is certainly one of the more original games this generation. The setting, power ups, and moral dilemma of rescuing "little sisters" or harvesting them is enough to solidify this as a very good game; certainly worthy of four out of five stars. But I'm confident in 5-10 years it'll be remembered as, "That was a really good game," instead of "That game is a masterpiece; it changed my life."
- The Sims — Get this: At 150 million copies sold, The Sims is the fourth best-selling video game franchise in the world and the best-selling PC game ever. Following that logic, that makes The Sims "better" than both Tetris and Grand Theft Auto, and that's just wrong. A highly accessible and fun game this definitely is. But most deserving of PC sales title? I'm not so sure.
But that's just me. When thinking of overrated PC games, what comes to your mind? Don't forget to state your reasons.
Read more: PC gaming culture
Comments
Technological progress is like an axe in the hands of a pathological criminal -Albert Einstein
Level 7
3063 ARP
Level 4
705 ARP
Level 1
50 ARP
Level 2
120 ARP
Level 5
845 ARP
Nah, I think the Big Daddys will be recognised by gamers for a couple more decades...
And why is nothing COD in that list? For all of the hype and excitement surrounding those games at launch time you'd think that George Lucas had just released a new Star Wars film... and almost every time without fail the new games get an average "meh" rating.
"A single dream is more powerful than a thousand realities." ~ J.R.R. Tolkien
Level 7
5071 ARP
It takes 47 muscles to frown,and 17 to smile.. It only takes 3 to end a life.. One shot, one kill.
Level 7
3741 ARP
The Sims is over-hyped as well but it does reach a broader audience than many other games. I know people whose girlfriends didn't really play any games but they played Sims.
Level 7
4914 ARP
Sims isn't necessarily overrated. I'd agree with you had I not played the game or played it only momentarily, but when you get sucked into that you stay stay there for a good period of time. If I felt like it actually had "hype", like to the extent CoD or any other blockbuster title, I'd agree with you but it doesn't. People are going to purchase it regardless of what its rating is because it is somewhat addictive and entertaining and regardless of it not being marketed as the game of the year and whatnot.
Level 4
555 ARP
"What is the music of life?" "Silence, my brother."
Level 7
2025 ARP
It got so hyped up as the successor to Oblivion and I feel like they took a lot of what made Oblivion fun out of it.
It's just a bunch of "run here, get this, run back" quests and pure boring skill grind :/
Level 1
65 ARP
http://battlelog.battlefield.com/bf3/user/XeNo-aKa-009/
Level 3
276 ARP
Level 7
1504 ARP
Level 6
1036 ARP
my time has come.
Level 7
6087 ARP
I don't try to be awesome, It's natural! So are potatoes, potatoes are natural :l
Level 7
1716 ARP
Level 7
1644 ARP
Wow.... just wow. You're comparing an entire franchise that took a lot more ingenuity, coding, art style, and storyboarding to make, to more or less a single game that isn't much more complicated than Tic Tac Toe. Grand Theft Auto and The Sims are incredibly different games as well; I'm not going to bash either franchise, but to say that one or the other is 'better' is not thought out well with the differences in genres alone.
Level 7
1719 ARP
Level 1
27 ARP
Level 1
39 ARP
New forums... Any Time Soon™
Level 7
8400 ARP
What defines you is how you react to disappointments.
Level 5
806 ARP
Level 2
242 ARP
Level 7
1839 ARP
Level 7
3366 ARP
Add Your Comment
You are not logged in. To leave a message you must Login First.