Unlimited PC play: You're gonna have to do better than that, Gamefly

December 20th, 2011

Realizing that games will soon follow movies and music to an all digital world, catridge and disc rental company Gamefly this week released a new download client and "unlimited play" service for PC games. While I'm encouraged by anyone contributing to the PC gaming ecosystem, I'm dissapointed in the new service for the following reasons:

  1. The "unlimited" library of games is terribly limited. Assassin's Creed and World of Goo look nice, but not a lot of other titles jump out at me. As such, why would any PC gamer pay $8/month to Gamefly to access said titles with an account? Even the game client, formerly known as Direct2Drive, is limited (no where near the number of games as Steam.)
  2. Gamefly primarily appeals to console gamers. When coupled with the above, this "unlimited PC play" service, available to all Gamefly members at no additional cost, feels more like scraps than a true, stand alone service, especially since almost all of the Gamefly members are heavy console users. Upwards of half of all PC gamers also own and play consoles, so I could see this working for some. But again, why use the service if it's even more lacking in games than even OnLive (which has its own issues with game shortages).

I'm willing to give Gamefly a grace period to ramp up the service, but I can't help but think this thing is half baked. Obviously game publishers are notoriously stingy in moving away from physical media, so that's a contributing factor. And I could see the service as a pro in introducing console gamers to the PC experience.

But for PC gaming, companies like Gamefly are gonna have to do a whole lot better to entice gamers away from the wonderful Steam.

That's just me, though. What do you think of Gamefly unlimited PC games? And would you be interested in an unlimited, Netflix style PC game service? If so, what would it take to interest you?

Read more: PC gaming stories

Comments

Page 1 of 2 1 2 
It's a great business model only if you have about 1,400+ games like Steam. But for Gamefly, you don't. Therefore, it's not worth it at all. OnLive could be very prosperous too if it actually had a lot more games available. Unfortunately, many of the big game publishers have not partnered up with Gamefly or OnLive, causing most people to ignore these services. I would only be interested in these services only if they just simply had a variety of games for me to play. Now imagine if Steam suddenly did what Gamefly did or what OnLive does, oh boy, that'd be extremely tempting.

New forums... Soon™

1
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
8045 ARP
6545/2147482148, 2147475603 ARP to go
6545/2147482148, 2147475603 ARP to go
I have to agree. I'll stick with steam for now, but continue to watch this and the onlive service to see where they end up.

Yesterday is gone and tomorrow never comes!

2
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
3305 ARP
1805/2147482148, 2147480343 ARP to go
1805/2147482148, 2147480343 ARP to go
i think ill stay at steam´...

http://eu.alienwarearena.com/groups/guild-wars-2-gold-farmers/

3
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
2387 ARP
887/2147482148, 2147481261 ARP to go
887/2147482148, 2147481261 ARP to go
There is no competition for Steam yet, it has a very polished system and a great company behind it.-

Cum somnus finit - Razgriz surget iterum

4
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
2308 ARP
808/2147482148, 2147481340 ARP to go
808/2147482148, 2147481340 ARP to go
The "unlimited" library of games is terribly limited.

=> Indeed, that's THE huge problem.

"It's Nice To Be Important , But It's More Important To Be Nice"

5
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
4776 ARP
3276/2147482148, 2147478872 ARP to go
3276/2147482148, 2147478872 ARP to go
I'm sure Gamefly will add more games. They don't have to add as many as steam, just as many as what Direct2Drive has.

6
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
1644 ARP
144/2147482148, 2147482004 ARP to go
144/2147482148, 2147482004 ARP to go
I'm definately sticking with steam for now, I've always wanted to try out gamefly because of what they say about it, but after reading that, I changed my mind...

7
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 2
120 ARP
20/150, 130 ARP to go
20/150, 130 ARP to go
As interesting as that sounds I like to own my games rather than have them rented out from someone else. It is an amazing deal however.

Anything worth having is worth working hard for.

8
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
6397 ARP
4897/2147482148, 2147477251 ARP to go
4897/2147482148, 2147477251 ARP to go
Steam has pretty much covered the digital PC scene.
I don't think you can do much to sway people away from it from all their crazy sales and giveaways.
Sticking to Steam

9
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 4
506 ARP
6/250, 244 ARP to go
6/250, 244 ARP to go
neat

10
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 6
1027 ARP
27/500, 473 ARP to go
27/500, 473 ARP to go
i was in the beta for this not bad but don't care for much

my time has come.

11
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
5894 ARP
4394/2147482148, 2147477754 ARP to go
4394/2147482148, 2147477754 ARP to go
They will expand in the future.

"He who controls the present, controls the past. He who controls the past, controls the future.

12
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 5
818 ARP
68/250, 182 ARP to go
68/250, 182 ARP to go
Currently, they don't have much of a chance against Steam.

Enjoying my new life in California :)

13
Posted Tuesday, December 20th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
3117 ARP
1617/2147482148, 2147480531 ARP to go
1617/2147482148, 2147480531 ARP to go
Gamefly isn't my thing, and OnLive has lag related issues. Anyone with slow internet aren't going to have fun, plus it'll take up lots of bandwidth probably so for those with no unlimited bandwidth, would suck. Dono much about gamefly but if there's only a limited amount of games, it's probably terrible right now but i'm sure they'll add more

14
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
1775 ARP
275/2147482148, 2147481873 ARP to go
275/2147482148, 2147481873 ARP to go
Sigh. The price looks fine, but they just don't have a great library... Just can't see this going well...

15
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
1661 ARP
161/2147482148, 2147481987 ARP to go
161/2147482148, 2147481987 ARP to go
Steam still better.

Claudio Olivaes - killerPOA Brazilian FPS Player - Old School MSN olivaes@hotmail.com

16
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 1
89 ARP
88/99, 11 ARP to go
88/99, 11 ARP to go
definewikipedia said: It's a great business model only if you have about 1,400+ games like Steam. But for Gamefly, you don't. Therefore, it's not worth it at all. OnLive could be very prosperous too if it actually had a lot more games available. Unfortunately, many of the big game publishers have not partnered up with Gamefly or OnLive, causing most people to ignore these services. I would only be interested in these services only if they just simply had a variety of games for me to play. Now imagine if Steam suddenly did what Gamefly did or what OnLive does, oh boy, that'd be extremely tempting.


I couldn't agree more. Sadly, publishers aren't going to enter a contract with Gamefly or OnLive unless they have a player base to support the content they would be providing, and without the support of publishers the player-base of both services is going to remain limited.

17
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
1719 ARP
219/2147482148, 2147481929 ARP to go
219/2147482148, 2147481929 ARP to go
I have world of goo and I don't need anything else from that website :D

It takes 47 muscles to frown,and 17 to smile.. It only takes 3 to end a life.. One shot, one kill.

18
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
3738 ARP
2238/2147482148, 2147479910 ARP to go
2238/2147482148, 2147479910 ARP to go
Though, if they market well their player base will increase and they will be able to get a substantial number of subscribed players; thus, having the possibility of landing a contract with a game producing company.

Those who do understand thinking, those who think do not understand doing.

19
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 6
1123 ARP
123/500, 377 ARP to go
123/500, 377 ARP to go
dodolidot said: Steam has pretty much covered the digital PC scene.
I don't think you can do much to sway people away from it from all their crazy sales and giveaways.
Sticking to Steam



And the sooner that other companies realise this, the better! (I'm talking to YOU, Origin!)

"A single dream is more powerful than a thousand realities." ~ J.R.R. Tolkien

20
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
4957 ARP
3457/2147482148, 2147478691 ARP to go
3457/2147482148, 2147478691 ARP to go
Does not seem worth it to me... Steams games our just unmatchable currently.

21
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 1
12 ARP
11/99, 88 ARP to go
11/99, 88 ARP to go
uma ótima ideia

22
Posted Wednesday, December 21st, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 2
213 ARP
113/150, 37 ARP to go
113/150, 37 ARP to go
As a past and present member of Gamefly, I love the service and couldn't be more happy with my mail delivered rentals. But the digital client proved very disappointing for me. I check it about once every week for anything new added to the unlimited PC play category, which hasn't yielded results since I started in the beta. As for buying games digitally, there are really no incentive to do so through the client. I doubt they'll ever be on par with Steam.

23
Posted Thursday, December 22nd, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 2
108 ARP
8/150, 142 ARP to go
8/150, 142 ARP to go
Not to interested right now. Maybe in the future if they step it up a little add some titles i will consider it.

xXNoobtubedXx

24
Posted Thursday, December 22nd, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
7628 ARP
6128/2147482148, 2147476020 ARP to go
6128/2147482148, 2147476020 ARP to go
Steam is way better, sorry but it's true :P

25
Posted Thursday, December 22nd, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 4
683 ARP
183/250, 67 ARP to go
183/250, 67 ARP to go
Page 1 of 2 1 2 

Add Your Comment

You are not logged in. To leave a message you must Login First.